What Happens Outside the Fifteen-Minute Visit

After decades in cancer survivorship, Dr. Mercedes Castiel began looking more closely at everything patients carry outside the examination room. Her next chapter has brought a different kind of medical practice, more control over her time, and an increasingly convincing claim to Bergen County residency.

There is a great deal that happens before a patient enters an examination room.

By the time the physician walks in, there may already have been weeks of phone calls, an insurance problem, several nights spent searching unfamiliar medical terms, a friend enlisted to drive, a child handed off to someone else for the afternoon, a spouse trying to remember the questions they had promised to ask. There may be a pathology report sitting in a portal and an entire family quietly rearranging itself around a diagnosis.

Dr. Mercedes Castiel spent much of her career on the other side of that examination-room door.

For seventeen years, she practiced at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, where she eventually headed general gynecology and developed and directed one of the country’s early multidisciplinary women’s cancer-survivorship programs. Her work occupied a particular corner of medicine, caring for women whose lives had been altered by cancer and its treatment, sometimes long after the most acute part of their illness had passed. Fertility could change. Menopause could arrive years before it was expected. Genetic testing could introduce an entirely new set of questions about risk, children and the future. Survival itself could create problems for which patients had not known to prepare.

 

What Happens Outside the Fifteen-Minute Visit
Dr. Mercedes Castiel, whose career in cancer survivorship has evolved into a new chapter in medicine, family and, increasingly, Bergen County.

 

Castiel remembers Memorial Sloan Kettering with enormous affection. She describes getting the job there as feeling as though she had “won the lottery,” and credits the institution, its leadership and her mentors with allowing her to grow into the physician she became.

The cracks she began noticing were not necessarily inside the medicine.

Sometimes they appeared when an insurance plan changed.

A patient might have spent years with physicians who knew the history of her disease, remembered the treatments she had endured and understood the questions that had accumulated along the way. Then an insurance change could alter where she was covered for care. Castiel encountered the problem again after moving to NYU, where participation in insurance plans differed.

For someone healthy, finding a new doctor can be irritating. For someone with cancer, the prospect can feel considerably larger.

“It is hard enough to find a physician you connect with in general,” Castiel told us. “But with a complex, chronic medical condition like cancer, having to figure out how to continue being a patient of the people who have held your hand throughout your journey can be overwhelming.”

She is careful about the distinction. Her frustration is not directed at the institutions where she worked, places she continues to speak about with respect. It is directed toward a system in which the continuity of an intensely personal medical relationship can sometimes hinge on an insurance contract.

 

“It is hard enough to find a physician you connect with in general. But with a complex, chronic medical condition like cancer, having to figure out how to continue being a patient of the people who have held your hand throughout your journey can be overwhelming.”

 

Castiel would eventually come to understand the patient experience from another vantage point. Cancer affected members of her own family, and she found herself doing what physicians so often do when illness enters their private lives: translating, calling, connecting, interpreting and trying to make an enormous medical system navigable for someone they love.

What stayed with her was how much of cancer care was taking place nowhere near a hospital.

There were meals to organize and children who still needed looking after, rides to appointments, houses that did not stop needing to be cleaned because someone was receiving chemotherapy. Friends accompanied patients to visits and sat through infusions. Relatives became note takers and interpreters. Coworkers filled gaps. People who had never imagined themselves as caregivers learned the practical choreography of illness almost overnight.

Castiel calls these people the “unsung heroes” of cancer.

Her experience with her own family also changed what she noticed about the conventional medical visit. A fifteen-minute appointment is rarely fifteen minutes with a physician. A medical assistant or nurse may take the vital signs and begin the history. A patient arriving within the permitted grace period may already push the doctor into the next patient’s scheduled time. One delay becomes another, and soon a physician who would very much like to sit down and listen is also aware of the waiting room filling outside.

Cancer is particularly poorly suited to a clock.

A patient may arrive with a question about medication and end up crying about recurrence. She may want to discuss fertility, sexuality, her children or the fear she has been trying not to mention to her family. Even a person who has lived with a diagnosis for years can be unexpectedly overwhelmed by it.

 

“No one can truly ‘see’ a patient in 15 minutes.”

 

“Seeing a patient goes beyond vitals, history and an exam,” Castiel says. “Sometimes they need to address more and, for me, I like getting to know them beyond the standard history.”

That requires something increasingly precious in medicine: time.

THE CONVERSATION

Dr. Mercedes Castiel sits down with Bergen Society founder Dana Corriel to talk about cancer survivorship, leaving traditional clinical practice, becoming a grandmother and the Bergen County life she has acquired along the way.

Castiel eventually created the Cancer Care Concierge, a practice built around the portion of illness that can be difficult to fit neatly into an appointment. She helps people understand what they are being told, prepare for decisions, find appropriate specialists, navigate appointments and make sense of a world whose language has suddenly become very technical. Her practice describes the work as independent guidance and advocacy alongside a patient’s existing medical team.

She has an analogy for the first days after a cancer diagnosis. It is like being asked to fly a plane without having been trained as a pilot.

The word cancer arrives first. Then comes a cascade of vocabulary: imaging, pathology, genetics, staging, treatment options. Decisions begin appearing before the person making them feels qualified to make any decision at all.

Castiel’s advice is less complicated than the circumstances. Ask questions. Ask them again when necessary. Use the social workers and other resources available through the institution. Read the material you are given. And when the people in your life offer to help, allow them to.

That last part may be easier to understand once you know something else about Mercedes Castiel.

She had six children.

Now she has grandchildren.

And this is where a story about a cancer-survivorship physician unexpectedly becomes a Bergen County story.

Castiel technically lives in Westchester, although her oldest daughter’s family has made the distinction increasingly academic. Her daughter lives in Bergen County with her husband and two children, and Castiel spends enough time here that her three-and-a-half-year-old grandson has developed a more practical understanding of the family geography.

Grandma lives with them.

Grandpa, apparently, lives in Westchester, and Grandma visits him there.

Castiel finds this hilarious. She also seems perfectly content with the arrangement.

“Becoming a grandmother is nothing short of magical,” she says. “I looooved being a mom. Clearly. I had six amazing children.”

 

Mercedes, at the Blood Cancer united event, where she received an award for her work.

 

There is something revealing in the way she talks about this stage of her life. When she was raising her own children, there was always something else requiring attention: school, activities, dinner, work, the house, the finances, the thousand pieces of family administration that disappear into the word parenting. Grandchildren have arrived without quite the same background noise.

She can simply be with them.

Her grandson takes her to his favorite places, and she takes him to hers. There are play spaces, Target and Starbucks, restaurants she has come to know, and a slime store at the mall where the initial price of the slime bears only a passing relationship to what one eventually spends after a small child discovers the charms that can be added to it.

She gets her manicures in Bergen County now.

At some point, residency becomes a technicality.

The career Castiel designed has made this possible. For the first time in her adult life, she says, she has substantial control over her schedule. She can help when one of her children needs backup. She can be present for the grandchildren. She can continue doing work she finds meaningful without organizing the rest of her life around the relentless geometry of a clinical schedule.

And something unexpected happened once she stepped outside that schedule: her professional world grew in other directions.

She gives invited lectures and continues her medical education. She writes. She has begun appearing on podcasts. A graduate student recently asked her to serve as an expert adviser on a master’s thesis, an invitation that delighted her partly because she had never imagined that particular role for herself.

The physician is still very much there. The shape of the work has changed.

 

“My concierge practice has given me flexibility for the first time in my adult life, while also continuing my career, which has always been so fulfilling.”

 

There is a temptation to describe a career change like Castiel’s as a departure from medicine. Her story feels more interesting when viewed as an accumulation of everything medicine taught her. Years of caring for women with cancer taught her where the medical questions end and the human ones begin. Helping relatives through cancer showed her how much labor occurs outside the clinic. Raising six children taught her something about the finite nature of time. Becoming a grandmother seems to have sharpened that lesson.

Her life now contains the pieces she wanted to keep: medicine, teaching, writing, family, expertise, usefulness. They simply occupy the calendar differently.

EDITORIAL THOUGHTWe tend to measure medical care by what happens in the room: the diagnosis made, the test ordered, the treatment prescribed. Castiel’s career raises another question. How much of caring for a person happens in everything medicine has placed outside the appointment?

During our conversation, I asked Castiel whether she would be happy if one of her grandchildren eventually chose medicine.

She did not have a tidy answer.

Medicine has given her a life she remains deeply grateful for. She describes caring for patients during vulnerable periods as a privilege. She also knows the length of the training, the emotional weight of the work and the bureaucracy surrounding modern practice. One of her daughters became a gynecologist and high-risk pregnancy specialist, following her mother into a profession that required many years before she reached her first permanent job.

Castiel hopes younger physicians will have a hand in shaping whatever medicine becomes next, perhaps nudging it toward a more human-to-human model of care.

Her grandchildren have plenty of time to decide.

For the moment, there are considerably more pressing matters in Bergen County. There are grandparents to visit, places to go and slime charms to select. There is a grandmother who spent much of her adult life working according to other people’s schedules and has finally reached a point at which an afternoon can stretch a little.

Nobody has allotted her fifteen minutes.

share this article:

Facebook
Threads
WhatsApp
Email
LinkedIn
Twitter

Still Curious? Here’s more